I taught a class yesterday that bombed….

…. and I mean, it absolutely bombed. It was awful. It wasn’t just that the students were a bit quiet. I know how to handle that, with the usual techniques of setting up good norms, doing a bit of small groupwork, even calling directly on someone, especially if I happen to know they have something to say (and I make sure I do know who has something useful to say). No. This was much much worse than that. They weren’t just quiet. They were bemused into silence. And I could hear myself just talking and talking, making things more and more complicated, in a vain attempt to help.

I kind of stake a lot of my reputation on being a good classroom teacher, first and foremost. If we’re honest, I probably show off about it a bit to the students (and you lot!). I don’t know how I’m going to look those young people in the eye when I next see them. It was embarrassing.

Various things coalesced to produce this horrible scenario.

Continue reading →

A Pedagogy of Refusal: Join us to meet Claire Timperley and Kate Schick at UCL Centre for the Pedagogy of Politics

We’d love it if ALPS readers would like to join us in-person at UCL in central London for an opportunity to meet Claire and Kate from Te Herenga Waka—Victoria University of Wellington, Ao​tearoa New Zealan​d to discuss ideas from their new upcoming book, A Pedagogy of Refusal. Please sign up on Eventbrite.

Continue reading →

Revalidation, the sequel

Happy start to the new academic year to those who celebrate! To mark the coming of September, we’ve asked Stephen Thornton, Reader in Politics at Cardiff University, to return to his 2023 blog about what an ‘ideal’ Politics/IR degree looks like to reflect on the outcome of his revalidation process. Thank you as ever to Stephen for the guest post!

So, nearly three years ago – having been tasked with leading the upgrade of undergraduate degree programmes in my department – I wrote a blog about my hopes and (mostly) fears regarding this revalidation process, as it was called. The blog led a few weeks later to an online event put on by UCL’s excellent Centre of the Pedagogy of Politics at which various learned and experienced folk, and me, discussed aspects of this process under the banner ‘What does a good Politics/IR degree look like?’ I still don’t know the answer to that, but, since then, I have played a role in transforming Cardiff University’s Politics and International Relations undergraduate curriculum. The number of modules we offer has been significantly reduced, degree pathways have been made more distinct, and a variety of new capstone projects have been added to the mix. I’ve also learned a few things about the revalidation process along the way, some of which might be worth sharing.

Continue reading →

A Slacker’s Guide to the Teaching Track

It’s been very fun being one of a rare breed: a Professor in an education-focused role! One really big perk has been getting invited hither and yon to talk about my career and give dubious advice. Since it’s August and hopefully even go-getting and driven academics are managing to slack off a little bit (with all solidarity and many apologies to the Admissions Tutors amongst us), I thought I’d take my chance to poke to a bit of fun at all the strategic careers advice out there and reflect on some of the ways I’ve managed to be modestly successful by ignoring it. No-one reading the ALPS blog in August is a slacker, admittedly, but if you have any aspirations to slack more, please pull up a chair….

Continue reading →

Inoculation and epistemic competence: training students to handle misinformation

We’re grateful for today’s guest post from Eloise Harding from University of Southampton, based on her recent presentation at the joint UCL Centre for the Pedagogy of Politics and Aspire conference at UCL. Eloise is a Senior Teaching Fellow in Politics and Director of Programmes in the Politics And IR department at University of Southampton 

Today’s Politics classroom is on the frontline of a battle against misinformation, disinformation, clickbait and bullshit, and we need to develop a pedagogy that can respond robustly to these challenges. I’m not claiming to have the perfect solution, but have spent the past three years developing some starting points.

Continue reading →

Assessment Literacy is a two-way street: A story of convenors and students learning from each other to use blog posts as assessment

Today we have a guest post from Louis Bujnoch and Luke Armstrong, both from University of Glasgow. As attentive readers know, I (Cathy) love a guided marking exercise and work with students on assessment criteria and ‘what makes work good’, so I thought this was great! Enjoy!

Essays are boring and we want more exciting, alternative formats of assessment – this is a common refrain from student feedback on assessments in politics and international relations at our institution. Where alternative assessment formats – briefing notes, blog posts, podcasts etc. – are being employed, however, students   often find that they are unfamiliar with these formats.  This leaves course convenors and instructors with the problem of how to introduce innovative assessments while still keeping instructions clear. This phenomenon presumably is not restricted to students at our institution, a Scottish Russell Group University, which is why we wrote up our attempt to square the circle of finding pedagogically more interesting ways of assessing, while also making sure students understand the expectations of the assessment. The following is a tale of assessment literacy – for both students and course convenors – and learning how to become better at implementing and writing a blog post assessment in a political theory course.  Good use of formative assessment is key, whereby formative assessments are constructively aligned and used to unpack the expectations of an assessment which might not be immediately apparent from assessment instructions.  Our new course, Contemporary Challenges in Politics, is an attempt to link contemporary political challenges and phenomena with political theorists and theories. Given that a core learning outcome lay in the connection between theory and contemporary events, and as readers of existing political theory blogs such as, Crooked Timber, we thought that setting a blog post as part of the assessment regime  was an appropriate way of encouraging students to reflect on political theories in ways that make their practical relevance clear.  A common response to theories from students is to say “well, it’s just a theory”.  Through the blog post, we hope students can begin to understand how theories are more than this, and how they are important to how we understand the world.  Without theory, the study of politics would be unsystematic and without any sense of what should be done in response to its problems. 

Of course, using blog posts as assessment in Politics and IR classes is not “radically” innovative anymore. While not a standard format, they are already being used at many institutions in a variety of guises, ranging from single blog entries on a specific topic to iterative assessments where students write multiple blog posts across a semester or even year of study, sometimes even on a live, publicly accessible blog. For the purposes of our course and our assessment regime, we decided to stick to the former and have students write a single blog post of 1,500 words on a topic of their choosing.   On the first year of the course, we offered very loose instructions.  We asked students to think of a recent issue which illuminated a core concept within political theory, such as justice or freedom.  Students were instructed to show how the concept was relevant to the issue, and helped us make better sense of it, while also writing in a style that was accessible for a wide audience.  Finally, the students were told that, while they could write in a more “casual” and less academic style which was accessible to a wide audience, the blog post still had to include references. 

Students told us that they found these instructions too broad and unclear.  While we provided examples of good blog posts on Crooked Timber and other blogs, students weren’t sure what made these posts “good”.  For the second year of the course, we expanded on what made for a good blog post.  We offered one example of a ‘real life’ blog post, highlighting what was good about it and why.  Nevertheless, some students still struggled with the assessment format.

With innovative assessments, or at least less traditional forms of assessment, there is a process of learning for educators as much as students when it comes to understanding the requirements of an assessment.  To better understand the form of assessment, while also making the instructions clearer, we have designed a new formative assessment.  For the formative assessment, students will be asked to look at a post published on a blog by political theorists.  They will then consider how they would assess it in accordance with the marking rubric, which will be the same rubric against which their own work will be marked.  Our aim is for students to better understand how to develop their responses to innovative assessment, while understanding our expectations of them.  Through evaluating a blog post together with students, we can treat the task of unpacking the hidden expectations of assessment as a joint endeavour.  At the point at which the formative assessment is complete, our hope is that our students will better understand why we employ blog posts, and how to write one effectively, while we will hold a clearer understanding of how our students approach less traditional assessments. 

Generally, through this formative assessment, we aim to provide students with an understanding of how the assessment works, and what we as educators are looking for in their posts.  This is, however, a two-way learning process whereby students better understand the marking process, but we as educators also understand how students approach less traditional forms of assessment.  As assessment forms are diversified, with less focus on traditional assessment, we need to better understand how students think about assessments, and their concerns about such forms of assessment.  Newer forms of assessment can better equip students with tools suited to a quickly changing job market, particularly in the AI age, by showing students how to apply the theoretical tools of academia to the real world.  However, we cannot assume that students immediately understand what is expected of them, or that they see the benefits of non-traditional assessments. 

I blame Cathy….

Today we have a guest post from Dr Terry Hathaway who (un?)justly blames me for his recent excellent work!

Terry works at the University of York, teaching Norwegians about the wonders of British culture, politics, and pubs. His primary research focus is the power of corporations, which he is currently writing a book on. You can find Terry on Bluesky at @terryhathaway.bsky.social or contact him at terry.hathaway -at- york.ac.uk

I did something rather stupid recently. I listened to a paper at the PSA Teaching and Learning Network conference and, unfortunately, was inspired

The misfortune with this inspiration is that it meant much more work, and it meant much more work just before term started when I had roughly zero time on my hands. The lesson of the story is, clearly, don’t be inspired (and certainly don’t go to the PSA TLN conference or you too could be inspired by great teachers).

Continue reading →

The role of pedagogical research in education-focused careers: (eventually) joining the conversation

This guest post is (unless anyone else gets in touch to contribute!) the last in our short series on pedagogical research/SoTL and its role in education-focused careers. It is by Andy Judge, who is a Senior Lecturer in Politics and International Relations at University of Glasgow and an editor at Politics journal.

As an editor at the Politics journal, I read a lot of scholarship. While most of the articles we publish are disciplinary research articles, we receive a fair number of teaching-focused manuscripts. Most of these are assigned to me as associate editor, along with my excellent colleagues Karen Wright and Niccole Pamphilis. This gives me a distinctive vantage point on the role of the scholarship of teaching and learning within our disciplines.

Continue reading →

The role of pedagogical research in education-focused careers: Getting started in learning and teaching scholarship and why you should do it

This guest post is the next in our short series on pedagogical research/SoTL and its role in education-focused careers. It is by Chris Huggins, who is an Associate Professor and Director of Academic Programmes at the University of Cambridge.

Tune back in for more in this series

As part of a roundtable discussion at the 2025 Political Studies Annual Conference in April, I was asked to reflect on my experience with learning and teaching scholarship, how I got started, and why learning and teaching scholarship was important to me.

Continue reading →