In mid-September 2025, we started a new series, “Office Hours: Year One”, where three first-year tenure-track professors from different institutions reflect on their experiences throughout the first year. See Part 1 here. We are back with Part 4, and spring is upon us! In this post, we are checking in to see how things are in their first second semester, and whether goals are holding up.
Thank you again to Dr. Brooklyn Walker (University of Tennessee-Knoxville), Dr. Charmaine Willis (Old Dominion University), and Dr. Jennifer Ostojski (Indiana State University) for contributing and letting us get a glimpse at the first-year life.
Brooklyn Walker: The daffodils and dogwoods are blooming – spring is here! And so is the halfway point of my first spring semester at UTK.
This semester, I’ve added a second class, Religion and Politics, to my schedule. It’s a new course prep and has been a lot of work. When I’m designing a new course, I often feel like I’m weaving, holding threads of course objectives, course schedule and structure, assignment scaffolding, unit arc, daily class session objectives, and lecture/activity construction.
There are parts of the resulting tapestry I’ve really liked. The entire course is structured around a course question, and every class session ends by reflecting on how the day’s material relates to the course question. One of my students recently observed that, every day, he flip-flops on his answer because he’s learning more information and is having to think in more nuanced ways. And I thought, ‘Bingo! That’s what success looks like.’
One of my biggest concerns was teaching this topic in this political climate. The first day, I told students that there are lots of ways to study religion. We can take a personal/ devotional approach, a humanities approach, or a social science approach. Each addresses different types of questions and uses different tool kits. I think this helped. It’s allowed me to emphasize falsifiable hypotheses, the importance of data, ever-present uncertainty about estimates, the idea that social scientists deal in averages and probabilities and not absolutes, etc. We’ve been able to tackle hard conversations about how religion intersects with democratic values, race, and gender with nuance and humanity.
But other sections of the tapestry feel too busy. I asked students to visit a congregation at the beginning of the semester, hoping it would generate ideas for their literature reviews. They seemed to enjoy the experience, but I think it cramped the literature review scaffolding schedule. Some class activities have flopped or lectures felt stale. I’ll definitely need to dedicate time this summer to reweaving some parts of the course.
After feeling stuck for most of the summer and fall, the research feels like it’s finally moving. I’ve had 4 acceptances so far in 2026! These recent publications explore Christian nationalism’s relationship to punitiveness and political violence support; Christian nationalism as an emerging identity, and why teaching pro-social religious values isn’t enough to undo the negative effects of Christian nationalism. I’m sitting on some data I’m excited to explore and am starting to gather data for other projects. There are some fun projects in the pipeline about religious pluralism and religious gender worldviews. Did you know that there’s a growing movement to repeal the 19th Amendment? Normatively concerning, but fascinating to work on.
The biggest stress I’m feeling at this point in the semester is conference preparation. ‘Attend conferences,’ they say. ‘Use conferences as accountability for writing,’ they say. ‘Work with coauthors who are enthusiastic about the work,’ they say. That’s how you end up with 5 papers, 2 discussant roles, and a roundtable chair position at MPSA. And 6 more papers for conferences in the summer and fall. Fortunately, my co-authors are some of the most brilliant, hardworking, and generous people I know. Even though I’m buckling up for a busy season of writing, it’s bound to be interesting.
Finally, “balancing work and life is hard” is becoming my refrain in each of these posts. There are great things happening outside of work. Birthday celebrations! Family time! Building community with Knoxville people! Reading books for fun! It feels like I’m constantly reassessing how all the pieces of life fit together, but the stress of the transition to Knoxville is finally dissipating. This semester, for the first time, the refrain feels less like a complaint and more like something I’m actually figuring out.
Charmaine Willis: This semester, as I mentioned previously, I am teaching one course (a graduate version of a course that I’ve taught a few times, including last semester, at the undergraduate level). I have a few reflections on the teaching load and research vs. teaching balance. First, I think new assistant professors (of any kind) who have previous teaching experience have an advantage in that balancing research and teaching is not new. I’d taught several semesters when I was ABD, some with two courses, while I was writing my dissertation and producing research. During the past few years, I was a visiting assistant professor, where I had 2-3 courses in addition to needing to produce research to be competitive on the job market. Not that I have any great advice regarding this balance, but it is a balance with which I am quite familiar.
That said, one common piece of wisdom here is that teaching will take up as much time as you allow it. While I am quite familiar with this notion (and believe that it is true), I have been pretty good about relegating teaching-related tasks to one day a week (at least for most weeks). This, however, brings me to my second point, which is that this wisdom is true for basically anything. So, while I’m only teaching once a week, my non-teaching days have been full, and not just with research. I’ve taken on a few professional development items that have taken up time (both teaching-related and research-related), but worth it. In the past few months, I’ve participated in several department-related and university-related events, including being the keynote speaker in our graduate program’s annual conference! And obviously, I have continued with service-related and research-related tasks, such as going to meetings and conferences. These were all good and valuable things, but I previously hadn’t really considered these when thinking about how my time would/should be spent.
In addition to balancing research articles and teaching, I’m also writing a book, so I am learning to balance all of those things in addition to the “extracurricular activities” mentioned above. Since ISA, I’ve tried to prioritize my book research/writing while also allowing time for teaching and other research. That said, I am still trying to figure out how to account for the extra activities in my weekly planning and time management as well.
Beyond this balancing act, the semester has been personally challenging, though I am starting to feel that the worst is behind me. Without going into too many details, my husband and I had to move AGAIN, as we had a short-term lease that couldn’t be renewed, and my father was recently diagnosed with osteoporosis and some compression fractures in some of his vertebrae, which entailed being with him in Vermont for several weeks. Of course, my institution, Old Dominion University, was the site of a shooting in March, which has affected everyone in some way, whether they were present or not at the time. Our students, staff, and faculty eagerly await the end of the semester/beginning of summer to help with the healing process. All of these details are to say, however, that many unforeseen things can happen during the course of the semester that can inhibit you from being as productive in your research as you plan.
Jennifer Ostojski: I feel like the semester has barely started and here we are already scheduling final exams. It’s been interesting so far: some writing has gotten done, some things have been submitted to the reviewer gods. So on the research front, I feel like things are moving ever so slowly – but they are moving. On the teaching front, despite only having two classes, it does feel at times like I am teaching 100 classes. And that is probably my own doing. I have one repeat class, and yet, I decided to up-end my prep from last semester and charge ahead with a new way of thinking about the class. I enjoy it, but it also means that I am doing once again new prep. I will post about this at a later time on ALPS, but it is bringing me a lot of joy to see this new class format come to life.
As someone teaching Comparative, IR, and (this semester) EU Politics, I have to admit that world events make it at times hard these days to simply fall back on our discipline and explain things through theory/structures/patterns. It’s not necessarily that I cannot explain it, but it is difficult to explain and provide rhyme or reason – in particular when our students ask us questions as they are also trying to make sense of the world around them. I am reassured, though, that I am not the only one feeling this way in our discipline: ISA, for instance, hosted a virtual session on April 15, 2026, to create a forum to address this unsettled state amongst educators.
I am continuously learning and developing in my role – not just as an educator and researcher – but also as a member in my institutional community. I have taken on a first couple service roles this spring, focusing on student-facing and research focused positions, which I have so far enjoyed quite a lot. Although it does add to the overall already full plate, it has been an excellent opportunity to meet people across departments and colleges, which I find invaluable. Similar to Brooklyn, I am beginning to enjoy hobbies again in my life: some other first-years and I have started a monthly book club, where we read and discuss fiction and also catch each other up on life. It somehow reminds me a bit of my grad student cohort: there is something about bonding with folks who are experiencing the same journey and thus “get it”. Nonetheless, I am looking forward to the summer and the scheduling easing just a little bit.
PS: No one in grad school prepped me (us) for the madness that small kids adds to your day-to-day life. I was out for two (!) weeks in March because of daycare toddler diseases. My little walking petri-dish, who is very adorable, does not mesh well with the academic calendar and expectations. Kudos to all other folks with goobers on the tenure-track.



