I have, barring a few late submissions that will slowly filter in over the coming days and weeks, finished marking for the summer. Generally, the quality of the assessments has been good and it’s always satisfying to see how students have developed their thinking and their work over the semester.
Obviously, one of the things we assess when examining students’ academic work is how they engage with and reference literature. Despite guidance and recommendations on literature (i.e. on module reading lists and suggestions for journals that particularly fit the brief of a given course etc.) there are still some significant differences in how students approach sourcing for their work.
So, fresh out of marking, I have been pondering how, next semester, I can help students further engage with considering the quality and relevance of the sources that are making up their reference lists. With that in mind, I am thinking of running a brief in-seminar exercise I am calling ‘Reference lists: The good, the bad, and the ugly’.
The plan is this – I’m going to give students three reference lists and then ask them, in small groups, to discuss and pass judgement on the quality and relevance of the respective lists. As the name of this exercise makes clear, the examples will vary in quality. Let’s imagine the essay title ‘To what extent is the European Union a successful environmental actor?’, the three reference lists would look something like this (I’ll limit myself to four or five references in each list simply for blog-post brevity, in the actual exercise I’d probably go with something a bit longer:
Reference list 1
Kulin, J., Johansson Sevä, I., & Dunlap, R. E. (2021). Nationalist ideology, rightwing populism, and public views about climate change in Europe. Environmental politics, 30(7), 1111-1134.
Lenschow, A., & Sprungk, C. (2010). The myth of a green Europe. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 48(1), 133-154.
Oberthür, S., & Dupont, C. (2021). The European Union’s international climate leadership: towards a grand climate strategy? Journal of European Public Policy, 28(7), 1095-1114.
Schreurs, M. A., & Tiberghien, Y. (2007). Multi-level reinforcement: Explaining European Union leadership in climate change mitigation. Global Environmental Politics, 7(4), 19-46.
Wurzel, R. K., Connelly, J., & Liefferink, D. (Eds.). (2016). The European Union in International Climate Change Politics: Still Taking a Lead?. Taylor & Francis.
This list is one that I would class as ‘good’. Here the references are made up entirely of high-quality academic sources, primarily peer-reviewed journal articles but also with an edited collection included. Top marks.
Reference list 2
BBC News (2021). Climate change: EU to cut CO2 emissions by 55% by 2030. BBC News. 21 April 2021. Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-56828383.
Joshi, M., Joshi, A., & Bartter, T. (2025). The impact of climate change on respiratory health: current understanding and knowledge gaps. Current Opinion in Pulmonary Medicine, 31(2), 79-88.
Van Rensbergen, A. (2025). Trump 2.0: A test for the EU’s global climate leadership. The Parliament Magazine. 5 January 2025. Available at: https://www.theparliamentmagazine.eu/news/article/trump-20-a-test-for-the-eus-global-climate-leadership.
Woodhouse, A. (2020). How car manufacturers are adapting to EU emissions targets. Autotrader. 18 June 2020. Available at: https://www.autotrader.co.uk/content/news/how-car-manufacturers-are-adapting-to-eu-emissions-targets?refresh=true.
This is the reference list that I would label as ‘bad’. Most of the references here are weblinks, primarily news sources and show no engagement with any critical, academic approaches to the topic. Where a journal article is included in this list, it is from Current Opinion in Pulmonary Medicine. While I’m sure this is a fantastic journal for those interested in all things pulmonary, it is somewhat less relevant on an EU studies or environmental politics course. Getting students to think about the subject relevance is something that seems to be, in my experience, more of an issue in the latter field, where hard-science journals are often used as quick and easy references for rushed students but that do not actually show any strong engagement with relevant literature.
Reference list 3
Biedenkopf, K., & Petri, F. (2019). The EU as a global regulatory power? The case of environmental regulation in Asia. Asia Europe Journal, 17(4), 487–501.
Böhringer, C., & Roche, M. M. (2020). The EU ETS and the European Green Deal: Can they work together? Energy Economics, 91, 104874.
Buzogány, A. (2015). Governance by diffusion: EU environmental policy and the Eastern neighbours. Journal of European Public Policy, 22(6), 801–820.
Liefferink, D., Wurzel, R. K. W., & Connelly, J. (2009). Leaders and laggards in environmental policy: a framework for analysis. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 27(5), 879–894.
Mehlum, I., & Welfens, P. J. J. (2019). EU climate policy and the Green New Deal: An economic assessment. International Economics and Economic Policy, 16, 669–695.
We have had The Good and The Bad so, you could probably hazard a guess about how I’m going to class this reference list – but what makes this list The Ugly? Surely, this is a list of references quite similar to that found in Reference list 1, composed entirely of high quality academic sources? Well, there’s one key problem here. None of these sources actually exist. Whilst these are real academics and real journals, these articles are the result of GenAI hallucinations. This is the smoking gun of discovering student AI usage – something that, based on my own experience and on a number of Whatsapp group chats that have been alight with discussions of this over the last few weeks, is not a rare occurrence. Some students genuinely don’t seem to know that when they ask GenAI for a “reading list” (obviously they are not following up by reading sources that do not exist) for an essay they are being served up material that simply isn’t real.
My hope is that running an exercise like this (albeit, as I noted above, with longer reference lists) will give students a chance to sit around together and get to discuss what makes a source worth sourcing. There are still some details I’m working out – do I label this exercise ‘the good, the bad, and the ugly’ when I present it to the students, so they have some guide for the difference between the lists? Or do I leave that open and see how it lands in practice? Is including Reference list 3 a mistake? Is it training students to quickly double check their generated reference lists on Google Scholar but still not actually driving them to read the literature? As always, any ideas/ suggestions are greatly appreciated!

‘In this world there’s two kinds of people…’ but three kinds of reference lists?