
We’ve reached part 4 of Dr. Terry Hathaway’s 4-part guest post series! Terry works at the University of York, teaching Norwegians about the wonders of British culture, politics, and pubs. His primary research focus is the power of corporations, which he is currently writing a book on. You can find Terry on Bluesky at @terryhathaway.bsky.social or contact him at terry.hathaway -at- york.ac.uk
The final lecture in the Stories of Power series is about power at its deepest, concerning an individual’s narrative construction of identity and the role of social stories in such a construction. Now, this is a tricky topic to talk about because to talk about the construction of identity is, in many ways, to imply that someone’s identity is not inherent, which can be understood by students as saying their identity – which can often be felt on a very visceral level – is inauthentic.
The way I’ve found around this issue is to share stories from my own life (including things like how I learned to read when I was 7, but then finished my PhD when I was 26, or how I once hit someone with a tractor, and have broken my own nose in a fight) that I could use as evidence of some broader stories that say who I am to the world (an educational hero’s journey with the first two, stupidly reckless with the second two). This discussion lays the foundation for then talking about how people work to construct themselves from social stories of identity, such as race, nationality, disability, and gender, and how we use language, material goods, and images to portray our identity to the world.
The seminar that follows this lecture is an exercise in getting groups of students to tell a story about an individual that gives a clear sense of that individual’s identity. The way I’ve sought to capture this in an exercise is to simulate putting together a dating profile (which is something I also talk about in the lecture). The worksheet is available here.
To vary the student presentations at the end of the class, I have worksheets for each group with different prompts (lifted directly from dating app, such as “a fact about me that surprises people is…”). Each presentation is quite short – maybe a minute or two per group – and this could easily squash down into either part of a session or a shorter (than my usual hour) session.
In the debrief, I focus on how the students consciously used certain terms, hobbies, or interests to construct a sense of someone’s identity and that such an identity only comes through because of pre-existing shared meanings. I like to finish on the point that the exercise is one of showing a positive identity to the world, but that not all identities are positive, and many narratives are imposed on people rather than simply adopted. People can believe or be made to believe terrible things about themselves, and that such stories, when they have really sunk into someone’s skin, are the ultimate stories of power.
This exercise is quite a fun way to approach notions of identity and can work with a range of different political topics (particularly nationalism and political polarization) and could well be used in more sociological and/or literary areas.
Here are links to Parts 1-3 of the series. Thank you Dr. Hathaway!
– Part 1: Spin Doctors
– Part 2: Rallying Cry
– Part 3: Selling Drugs