Student partners, SoTL, and the Subject Benchmark Statement

When we employ student partners in the course of Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (SoTL) research, we are most likely to be working with students who are learning in our own institution and are also most likely undergraduate students who have only ever known that higher education institution. 

There are many benefits to this – it means we will know of their learning experiences and, importantly, that we can institute changes based on the research conclusions that will (hopefully) benefit those that have participated in the research. Working with undergraduate students, there is also the benefit that they will have a multi-year perspective of studying political science, whilst postgraduate taught students might be coming to politics after studying anything from a vast range of other subjects. 

However, there is an issue that I have been thinking about with this mode of SoTL research. How do we get our student partners to think ‘beyond’ their own experiences of political science education at their higher education institution? 

This is a question that matters. After all, we disseminate SoTL work partly in the hope that it will positively shape practices beyond our own. But if that work is suffering from too much introspectiveness, we could rightly be suspicious of any claims of generalisability. It might not always be possible to recruit student partners from a number of different institutions. Funds for SoTL projects are often held within separate HE institutions and have tight spending windows – limiting the opportunity for collaboration between departments at different universities. Therefore, the challenge is to try and get student partners to see themselves as students of political science and not only as students of political science at the University of Wherever. But how can we do this? 

This is a question that I was reflecting on earlier this year while putting together a project on changing assessment practices in my department. I was definitely interested in how students in that specific department felt about these changes but also wanted to systematically assess their perspectives as political science students in a way that would develop conclusions that could be applied in other institutions. So, I knew that trying to get student partners to think about studying political science in this wider sense was going to be key. 

I decided to provide student partners with the Subject Benchmark Statement: Politics and International Relations as a set piece of prior reading before their active participation in my SoTL project began. The Subject Benchmark Statement is described as follows:

Subject Benchmark Statements are not intended to prescribe any particular approaches to teaching, learning or assessment. Rather, they provide a framework, agreed by the subject community, that forms the basis on which those responsible for curriculum design, approval and update can reflect upon a course, and its component modules. This allows for flexibility and innovation in course design while providing a broadly accepted external reference point for that discipline.

This is to say, it’s not a rigid designation of what must or must not be featured on a Politics and International Relations degree. Instead, it provides a useful framing of how we might understand what a Politics and International Relations course might look like and might involve, in a general sense. 

I then began my first session with the project’s student partners discussing the document: What did they recognise from their own course? What did they find that was different? What did it tell them overall about studying Politics and International Relations? What did it mean to be a Politics and International Relations student and what skills does the degree develop? This was a short conversation but one that I thought would be helpful in setting the direction of the project, in helping the student partners to think beyond their own experiences of political science education at their higher education institution. 

While it is impossible to trace the exact impact that this practice had on the student partners’ thinking, I did find that the partners were able to critically engage in the way that I hoped they would – not only thinking about how changes in assessment process would impact the experience at the University of York but how they would shape the experience of political science students at other institutions. 

Therefore, this is a foundation of student partner research that I will likely reuse. Of course, a more powerful fix in terms of the generalisability of SoTL findings would be to have a more institutionally diverse group of student partners. However, I still think I would run this reading exercise with that mixed group of students in order to provide some common ground in their thinking around and understanding of the Politics and International Relations degree. 

If others have tried to give this kind of pre-project briefing to provide a foundation for SoTL research and have ideas of trying to boost the generalisability of SoTL findings, I’m always very keen to discuss, so do get in touch.