Interesting that the subject of student presentations has come up. Despite providing students with detailed instructions, exemplars, and advice, presentations were usually so excruciating that I simply stopped making them part of my courses.
This semester I’ve reintroduced them in my comparative politics course, which, accidentally-by-design, became an inverted classroom. I’m assuming many readers of this blog have heard of inverted classrooms — substituting activities in which student critique their own reasoning and that of others for the traditional “me talk, you listen” lecture. My problem was figuring out activities that would consume enough class time. So I decided to turn the close reading of texts, which I had used before as an individual activity, into group presentations.
Here are the directions for the presentations, somewhat condensed:
You and your group will be examining texts in detail and presenting your findings to the rest of the class. These close reading exercises are opportunities to train yourself to be a more thoughtful and efficient reader and to improve your communication skills. For each presentation, at least two members of the group will need to:
1. Select a paragraph from the reading assignment and analyze its structure as follows:
- Identify the paragraph’s topic statement
- Explain the topic statement
- Identify ideas/evidence used by the author to support the topic statement
2. Make references to the following characteristics of the paragraph being analyzed:
- WHO is the author addressing? WHO does the author imply he or she is, and who readers are?
- In both literal (the physical and historical universe) and textual (the storyline) terms, WHERE and WHEN is the paragraph set? Is there a difference between the literal and textual settings? If so, what is the effect of this difference?
- WHY did the author construct the paragraph in the particular way that it is constructed?
- WHAT mathematical or logical patterns exist in the paragraph? WHAT are the meanings conveyed by these relationships?
Because the class has seven groups of four students each, and each group presents a total five times during the semester. I get to completely avoid lecturing on the days that presentations are scheduled. Instead there is a fairly rapid sequence of different people talking at the front of the room interspersed with Q & A discussions between presenters, the rest of the class, and myself. Students get multiple, low-stakes opportunities to practice their presentation skills, and I get to avoid a week or two of torture at the end of the semester.
I can email the complete directions for the above exercise to anyone who wants them.